◂ Back to All Mysteries

Murder Among The Mateys

A Night of Buccaneers, Booty and Bloodshed!

How to Play

Is this your first murder? Don’t worry, we take all the pain out of the process.

You simply download the mystery materials, invite your friends, and follow the simple, easy-to-follow guide of how to set-up and run your own murder mystery party.

The night plays out in a simple 8-step process. It starts with guests arriving in costume, leads to a MURDER, and concludes when the mystery is solved.

Secrets for Success

What else do you need to know? Here’s some wisdom gained through hosting thousands of these parties!

All of the information regarding how to run your Murder Among The Mateys party can be found online at Night of Mystery. We highly suggest that you take time to look over our website and download the Murder Among The Mateys preview file. Upon reading the introduction file, it will give you a better understanding about how the parties are run and what to expect once you purchase a full mystery file.

If you still have question, the Frequently Asked Questions page at Night of Mystery is a great resource or you can contact us.

Since our games are custom written for the size of the party (ie, we don’t just create a mystery with 8 characters and then keep adding more characters to it), each mystery size is unique unto itself. That being said, going from 10-15 version to 15-20 version, will not only add in more characters, but it will change the storylines of the existing characters, and vice-versa in going from a larger version to a smaller one.

Because of this, WE STRONGLY SUGGEST you get a guest count before formally ordering. You can do so by downloading an invitation, inviting your guests and then purchasing your mystery once you have a more accurate number of people attending. Unfortunately, if you find yourself purchasing the wrong sized party, you will have to purchase another version of the mystery for the size you want unless you are moving from the 15-20 version to the 20+ version.
You can download an invitation here before ordering.

Check out some of these movies to get you in the mood and fuel your pirate fire: Treasure Island, Pirates of Penzance, Pirates of the Carribbean (any of them), Blackbeard The Pirate, Goonies, Black Sails (HBO tv series) or check out this complete movie list.

Provide an assortment of accessories to help your guests “get into character” including: eye patches, pirate hats, gold coins, pirate earrings, sashes, tooth blackout, bandanas, etc.

For even more party planning ideas, check out our Murder Among The Mateys Pinterest Board here.

Once you order, in your mystery packet you will receive directions and/or printables to make unique and original decorations specific to your party! Included will be:
• HOW TO MAKE PIRATE SAILS, TREASURE CHESTS AND TREASURE MAPS. (Directions and pictures to guide you.)
• DIRECTIONAL SIGNS (1 design)
• SALTY SEA DOG INN SIGN (1 design)
• GROWLER LABELS (4 designs)
• PIRATE BANNER (1 design)
• DESIGNED MENU (1 design you can personalize with your menu items)
• SIGNS (7 designs, 2 copies of each)
• TREASURE MAP (1 design)
• SAIL AND FLAG TEMPLATES FOR FOOD DECORATION (2 designs)
• PIRATE TATTOOS

Each month we highlight one of our customers who has posted on our blog and award them a FREE party!

To get your $5 coupon AND be entered in the Party Of the Month contest for a chance to win a FREE party, please email nompartyofthemonth@gmail.com

Don’t forget to add all the important details and party highlights that made your party one to remember! We love to hear about all of the hard work you, as host, put into your party. From the decor, to the food, costumes, whatever. As well as how you and your guests acted (and reacted!) throughout the night! Everything that made your party one your guests will never forget — tell us about it! And be sure to attach some pictures!!!

Upon submitting, we will email you back a coupon to use for $5 off your next party AND enter you in our “Party of the Month” contest, where you could win a FREE party! One submitted, you will not have to resubmit, but will be entered EVERY MONTH until your party wins!

Check out some of our past winners here! Night of Mystery POM Blogs

Thanks again for hosting with Night of Mystery and we can’t wait to hear all about your party!!!

What's Included

Murder Among the Mateys includes:

…and more!

Are You Up for 
the Challenge?